Should You Rent or Buy in Today's Market?

TL;DR

The old wisdom says renting is 'throwing money away.' The new reality is far more complicated.

Amanda Vance
May 22, 2024
·
6 min read

The 'Throwing Money Away' Myth

Owning a home involves throwing money away too: property taxes, mortgage interest, home insurance, and maintenance. Often, the unrecoverable costs of homeownership in the first five years exceed the cost of renting.

The 5% Rule

A helpful heuristic is the 5% rule. Calculate 5% of the home's value, divide by 12, and compare that to the monthly rent of a similar property. This accounts for capital costs, maintenance, and taxes.

Flexibility Has Value

Renting offers geographic flexibility and predictable monthly housing costs. If the roof leaks, you call the landlord. If you get a job offer in a new city, you leave when your lease ends.

Forced Savings vs Market Returns

Homeownership acts as a forced savings account through equity buildup. However, a disciplined renter who invests the difference between renting and owning into the stock market can often achieve comparable or superior wealth generation.

Want more financial clarity?

Sign up for our weekly newsletter for more practical advice.

Stay Ahead With RealProfits

Get practical insights, new tools, and smarter ways to think about money, work, and your future.